Decanting an Irrevocable Trust: What It Is and When to Use It

The term “irrevocable” sounds like something that can never change. However, with an irrevocable trust, this isn’t always the case. If you created, benefit from, or advise an irrevocable trust, there may be ways to update its terms as things change. Decanting an irrevocable trust is one option.
This article breaks down what decanting an irrevocable trust means, how it works, the limits, and who can guide you through the process.
What It Means to Decant a Trust
Trusts are legal arrangements that allow you to set assets aside for other people and decide how they’ll be managed and used. While decanting a trust may sound complicated, it boils down to the transfer of some or all assets from the original trust, called the “first trust,” into a new trust that has different terms, called the “second trust.”
A trustee, the person or organization responsible for managing the trust, may choose to decant a trust because the original rules no longer fit the beneficiaries’ needs. For example, an older trust might offer limited investment options. Moving its assets to a second trust could give the trustee more flexibility to invest in ways that better benefit the beneficiaries.
In some cases, you might not have the authority to make changes to the trust’s terms through decanting. Other times, beneficiaries may disagree with the proposed changes. When this happens, the trustee or beneficiaries may ask a court to resolve the dispute or consider judicial modification of a trust. However, decanting a trust without the courts can save you time and money on legal costs.
Common Reasons to Decant a Trust
Decanting is one approach to modifying irrevocable trusts when their original terms no longer fit current needs. A trust can operate for decades, and the beneficiaries’ needs, family circumstances, and tax laws can all change drastically over the years. Understanding why irrevocable trusts are created can help you decide whether proposed changes still support the trust’s goals.
Here are some of the more common reasons that you might consider decanting a trust:
- Fix unclear wording or mistakes: Unclear language, confusing instructions, and outdated provisions can make a trust difficult to manage and bring about disagreements. Decanting to a second trust offers a way to clarify the trustee’s responsibilities and how to distribute the assets.
- Move the trust to a different state: A trust situs change moves the trust’s administration from one state to another. Before moving a trust, consider how state taxes affect trust planning and whether the move could simplify administration.
- Combine or separate trusts: Trustees with multiple trusts can combine similar ones to reduce costs and paperwork. Likewise, they can separate a trust into multiple ones to meet the different needs of individual beneficiaries.
- Strengthen irrevocable trust asset protection: Beneficiaries who owe money to creditors or face a lawsuit could risk losing all or some of their inheritance. Decanting could allow the trustee to put stronger protections in place by changing how and when they can access trust assets.
- Support a beneficiary with special needs: When a beneficiary receives money from a trust, it could affect their eligibility for government benefits. Decanting may allow assets to move into a properly structured trust that covers additional care and expenses without impacting the beneficiary’s eligibility for government benefits. If Medicaid eligibility is a concern, it’s important to understand how irrevocable trusts interact with Medicaid.
It’s important to remember that decanting isn’t always an option for every trust or scenario. To understand whether it’s available and makes sense for specific situations, it's best to speak with professionals who specialize in trusts.
Circumstances When an Irrevocable Trust Can Be Changed
Irrevocable trusts usually limit the creator’s ability to cancel or change it. So, under what circumstances can an irrevocable trust be changed? Depending on the trust’s terms and applicable law, options may include decanting, asking a court for approval, or reaching an agreement among the required people. The trust itself may also give a trust protector authority to make certain changes.
Method
Who typically initiates it
Court involvement
Decanting
The trustee or someone else legally authorized to act
Usually not, but court review may be helpful afterwards
Court petition
The trustee, a beneficiary, or someone else with the legal right to ask
Yes, a judge decides if the change is allowed
Court-based agreement
The people who must agree under the law
Sometimes, court approval may be needed
Depending on state law and the proposed changes, a nonjudicial settlement agreement may offer another way for the parties to resolve trust issues without going to court.
Sometimes, the goal is simply to end the trust rather than update it. Unlike decanting, dissolution ends the trust and distributes its remaining assets according to its terms and applicable law.
Dissolving an irrevocable trust can be straightforward if its terms allow for it to happen. However, if beneficiaries disagree or its purpose still needs to be fulfilled, it can be much more challenging.
Why Switching to a Revocable Trust Is Rarely Simple
In some circumstances, it may be possible to change an irrevocable trust to a revocable trust. However, the process isn’t as simple as changing a label and regaining the right to withdraw assets and change beneficiaries at any time. Making a trust revocable could restore the trust creator’s power to change or end it. This could affect beneficiaries’ rights and how the laws and tax rules affect it.
Decanting, on the other hand, usually means moving assets into a second irrevocable trust with updated terms. This allows specific changes to happen while keeping the assets in a trust. In this sense, decanting may be able to address outdated rules without giving full control back to the trust’s creator.
How a Trustee's Power to Decant Depends on State Law
Your power to decant may come from several sources, including the trust document, state law, or rules established through court decisions. While the authority can come from more than one source, the trust document itself can limit or prohibit decanting altogether.
Comparing trust decanting laws by state can help you understand where different rules apply. Some states don’t have any specific decanting laws. Because of this, it may be more beneficial to move the trust to a state with more suitable laws that provide clearer rules or more flexibility to make changes. However, before moving the trust, advisors must confirm that the move is possible and which state’s laws would apply.
State law and the trust’s terms determine what changes are possible to an irrevocable trust. Even when the trustee can decant a trust, they must follow their legal duties to the trust and its beneficiaries. This includes respecting the trust’s purpose and acting in the best interest of its beneficiaries.
What Makes Delaware's Decanting Laws Stand Out
Delaware law offers a number of ways to manage and update trusts, including decanting. Under the Delaware trust decanting statute, Title 12, Section 3528, a trustee with the power to distribute trust assets can move them into a second trust unless the trust document says otherwise.
However, there are some limits that the trustee must follow. For example, the trustee must stick to the original trust’s rules for distributions and meet legal requirements that protect beneficiaries and certain tax benefits.
Delaware also offers other options, such as a directed trust. This trust lets designated advisors direct specific decisions, such as investments and distributions to beneficiaries. Directed trusts can divide responsibilities among people with expertise in different areas to help manage the trust more effectively.
Overall, Delaware offers several tools to adapt a trust as needs change. Advisors can help trustees figure out which options align with the trust’s goals and legal requirements.
Weigh the Limits, Costs, and Risks of Decanting
Decanting can offer flexibility, but it’s essential to understand the costs and risks before you take action. The value of decanting depends on what it can lawfully accomplish and the process required. Before decanting, consider these factors:
- Limits on beneficiary changes: Decanting doesn’t always allow a trustee to add or remove beneficiaries or change what they receive. The changes depend on the applicable law and the first trust’s rules for distributing assets.
- Restrictions in the agreement: The trust may limit or completely prohibit decanting.
- Trustee succession: Decanting may affect who serves as trustee next, but replacing or removing the original trustee isn’t always possible
- Costs: While there isn’t a universal price for decanting a trust, the total depends on the trust’s complexity and the changes needed. Expenses such as legal fees, tax advice, trustee reviews, asset valuations, transfer paperwork, and court proceedings can add up quickly.
- Tax consequences: Even when decanting is legally allowed, it could have tax consequences. Changing beneficiaries or how they receive assets can affect taxation.
With the costs and risks in mind, the best way to make a sound decision is to work with qualified legal and tax professionals. They can assess whether your proposed changes are possible and whether the benefits justify the costs.
How an Experienced Corporate Trustee Guides Decanting
Because decanting a trust requires more than writing a new agreement, experience is an important factor when choosing a corporate trustee. An experienced trustee can help you assess your options and guide the process by reviewing the trust’s terms and applicable state law to decide which changes are possible and if decanting is a suitable option.
Experience also plays a part in balancing the interests of current and future beneficiaries. For example, a change that helps someone receive money today could also affect someone entitled to assets in the future. The trustee must consider both groups and follow the legal duties.
Corporate trustees must also keep clear records that document the reasons for a change, the advice received, and what steps were taken. Working with experienced legal and tax professionals helps the trustee make informed decisions while accurately documenting the process. When comparing corporate trustees for irrevocable trust services, ask about experience with decanting and the applicable state law.
Start the Conversation About Updating Your Trust
If your trust’s rules no longer align with your family’s needs, talk with your financial advisor and legal or tax professionals. Together, they can help you determine what should change, if decanting is available, and how it compares to other options.
Arden’s personal trust and fiduciary services team is available to help you evaluate your options. As a knowledgeable partner, they can work with you to find the right approach that fits your needs. Understanding your trust’s terms, your goals, and the potential costs and tax consequences can help you make the right decision for the future of your trust.